Correspondence and editorial comments on the points at issue between Dr. Tweedie & Dr. Murchison concerning identical passages in their respective works on fever.

Murchison, Charles, 1830-1879.

Date:: 1863

Credit: Correspondence and editorial comments on the points at issue between Dr. Tweedie & Dr. Murchison concerning identical passages in their respective works on fever. Source: Wellcome Collection.

Provider: This material has been provided by The Royal College of Surgeons of England. The original may be consulted at The Royal College of Surgeons of England.

6/36 (page 6)

$£ i £• CD Dj § 00 CO s « ® a ^ >>2 e|l s ii W fcti © P I tM © o 5-i A-H3 2 A „o co CO .© K S- ^ 13 <33 .2 a CO fl O) c3 ■3 ^ .fl © A „© 03 'w Si © P rg s. o O o CD O oo £h . fl a3 - A CO CO rH 5_, 03 P a 03 « a © —I CD O pH CO I—I © fl 43 -d 03 § A P3 rd <D ^ § «> ® 3 [/) ■S3 43 fl 5-1 g O.S ‘p+c-sT 3 a®-* ^ O ri p- po» •- ® 3 fl h ° ® a -3 ^ P - Sgd « h fl © o3 -A -d ® , -t-H Sifl a s< a © © © © 5; A ^ g a CO ^ 03 PP fl D 5t <B 'TOO 2>o -A ^ ® ;g c3 ,d S a fl -d o Cl r? «H o -u PS O a © © -hs © pd fl a •A pa ,d ,p © a •<-< 43 43 Sh _ O cs w> a a,rt 00 a © -d 43 cc Sh C3 © r*4 d os • rH 43 03 Si bD O < a O? 3 rA <0? P o? co <fl d >j o3 .. S o3 - a a».s o na m -3 © © G a 5h.h dQ ri 5-< -i—i fl 3^0 ® ^ SH 03 c3 PA d © a c •- nO co © © g © © 2 03 '3 M “ o3 .C0 Q _d HH 03 O 'T «> rd O £r>C? fl ^ >4 >4 o3 03 © W 5-i ■ 03 Sh © O t»» d c3 d a © -^ © fl fl -d ^ Ah o ju <0 t/2 © Ah ^ CO ^ 03 (O? rag CO £ 3 ^ CD H fl rd CD HO sh q os o C4-4 ■P CO 35 T3 o © © © 1 pi CD T3 ^3 » bo GO 3,-S 6C © d Ph« fl rd © ^3 . © „ © d © ° 1 -*» 5h „ O? O © o3 CC Ci © H-H ft 54 h> .h d 8 © d c/2 CO <73 M o ,—i <33 a ^ U O Q) fl 5h m o M Pd pH o Q >) -U - I H “ • o ■d! a d 5-4 © © Ph 2 O CO © 5-t a -H> O © P p4 o3 © >. -t-3 o»o ^ o d © co GO C3 03 CO .d C3 5-4 © >■ * © <0? 5-4 PP . o sod Sh 'nH © O £d © a.a-a © Sh ■d P fl <o? 03 o O? rH «> >X? PP o Cu to ^ CO tn a® a M oo g ^ <oT CJ:S. H§ = J® H Ph rH © rH fq .2 § CD fl O C4-4 Cd r-H -A ^ -§ 2 SP 3 o § ® d PH O 53 - Dh W d Pd a « i-h o3 „<p.S ® 5< ai d S d_ d -rH It! ■e »p „ a h»h eg d rd g*.a> S4 g rH H04 d ^ 2.d-d ^ od-do ® Pr^-2 -2 £ 5? *J © Q rd d ■« <13 O bo G CO O fl rH ^ <D rd « a bo © a © •C ^ ^ § P3 fl ^ oS -4-> 'S. © o p a a C3 ,d © ?>-» i—> © 5-4 g g ^^H^ffl|g2rd m flpcSd «d^ a 03 g co n & f-4 6 CODO^. o3 5o> 5r ^ O ® o h|cO* co co Sh © © rd 03 d © 00 5-4 a M-c © 03 -H> GO rP. 03 © ^ ooodrd QJ -i_p _j Gh ^a.a S405 S’dd ©d © a ® ^.2 ^ ^ - © d aS^ra r© .a © C/2 cS -u 5-4 o &-o © d _p <2 -d ^ Pi a *> o co 03 CO D -4-> , 1—1 O ^ r{ H w o ® -d h> 03 © rd C/2 H_. -r -HO. H o h d ^fo^p g g r^d ^ ?P| g3 2.2 © g <D r? 'D y<* CO ^ - q O CD >73 a) co r£3 H-> CO rP^ P? “|g 11^ dS S3 „ s- - . 4-3 -r. O? © CQ ^ -d © +=> P bo © d d =« h d d ^ d o? d © H~> S3 S3 S «5 P © rd -H> o H o3 a ** m © 03 > d^ © Q-l W O © ” o a .a-rH ’S H 03 H rd a ^4^ © rH -2 O © 3 SO 03 > d ® M ^ GO d © fl o fl a © a •© _. , P O-CO § © H p ^ •^^rdi D 2 1—1 © *Sh (h OH O if S-t d o © H> r © - .3 P© <M 03 >,S pd c o C/J°0rc5f2 ©3f)ac,-,-2 h PP'tS P-,<1 Pd O nd .3 d o © d © fl © fld fl © — -H -fl H r© © =3 d © © P © hH 5h Sh ^ S4 © © 2 ^ ph-3 © cd o d - © 22d d © § § a H C3 d a CO ° r „ +j no A d ® i ° d Sh © © «2 2i.o © gi-w co d C3 <*3 nd © rt> © d <5 fl +* •' rd Sh 0b.© © 3 £ fl <2’2^l fe © - rd “ -4-3 d a o © GO fl o -U ©H 03 0 -A H-9 H O <13 Ah d © fl f—t CO ^ p C*H ^ o .fl nd fl fl § 2 §2 02 d ^ <s» §■§ flrd ^ w ^ fl >i c3 rf) C3 r*-5 r^2 -g rO c3 ^ »i 4H> O M CO •rH CD • rH q ^ ^2 r r^'fl 2 © d-3 fld r&oB PA ^rd .3 ^ 2 fl o © a K fj H H CO fl m +* fl fl flrs a ^ 2 g g ^ S3 rn S CM © cv> Sh 3£ cd s s £ A a'S w © © M © 3 fl rd K^rO? O CO o3 a fl Md«.H qO « os hh 03 od d 3 ©PH co ftfld«HH ©S-h l>43 5> © hT d -< ’S a 00 • ^4-H CD O pi CO © M ^ O A .-ag-Ud a § o s A ® - © wp o d © SPSK5 « M I •H> gH CO d o 2 T. trj © fl 53 H fl o p a P4 Sh © a a? a as ?> © O 5-t © o S4 a fl © 03 M s fl ^ D? d fl? Hi 4J r-j •rH C3 o .2 «w . . K* O CD 43 P Sh © d d ° »§5o $ »<S 43 H3> CO 03 d © © bo ' rH _ © rd § » C73 ^ o3 © _£H HH a **c a of ® « ^ 2 fl ®Q®. «3 _ d •r1 •— JHO 43 73 m 05 © 43 © rH rH 03 H P H « a d o CO O r a d o CD -4-2 ‘r-^H CD '■§ bofl o CO a a a A sh © “ _ r© a fl .SH 3=2 PA O fl? -fl aflQ w &P ^ 2 ro ^ CO •> ,<s> 00 hS CO <W 00 ^ ^ rpe HO 55i t-a-a «-p 13^o| • -O -dT1 .fll 40 .pH -fO —1 ^ M n W ^ Sh ^ « r 1 1 4J k © 0 r n I'A.fl S-g.S I fl A ^ a © 03 • rH — S4 P£ .rH fl? A « -a 2 a •a -0 3 p o a fl .A ^rfl o fl fl 12 g ^ fl © © ■H • — PP At.a q q S A © HH © _ ^ pO OJ 73 q co Jfl ^ © 40 flfo3<fl>3*!c;i22 . g^°fl ^ gP ft r S^rd ^.2 ^ g no a >rd © O ,35 ^ a W . rd fl <D 2 CD 1552 5 § ? ^ 2 3 bCt-d a a • rH H d '•I rd O o3 © - A fl <-© 2 g 03 t-H 1 © HO ^ CO m <D r~H rd o d a CO r/H « (D H-H ‘rH 2-d S ^fl g ©2^-a b^rf 2 gi . .O A ^ O Sh -D3 . k|<H P 43 >J ^ ©H 2 pg n3 c S3 © •« 43 a A CO o fl CO o > rH • rH (D rd s ^ © CO 1 © ; -a <-^2*2 'S 2 fl ^ C T .©_> 7; .5 00 ^ c ^ fl ©add© co © : oo ro r«o e o H ..SH ^ fl $ d m fl dr « © -A © A rD d 1+3 r © 2 2^1 o 3 © 3 ®13 a 1^13 a 22 © p 43 Sh A 3 © ® ° SH ^ S4 « O ® ® O © dfl © g2 HHS - ' S- O 43 P © © 5-t © Ah £ a a >1 o'0 03 P 03 © A rH |§1 ©5 © .3 • h r] ft 43 rH H o «H fl ■8 ftO r 8 gi •- © 43 n3 •S5 eo Cd A A -o O fl __. r—H - i® 43 © g © 03 Sh ^ A -d A © PH43 r-4 § okl-ScT* -. « Sh §i2 •« O S ^ «P S3 . o 2 fl ^ 5 ° •“ I fl 2 43' . O' g !2 © Hr. Ah >4 o CS cd Ah ^ 2 O* to +2 d ^ M f«H S»h O r—H pp 5 S3* <*> 03 ©HH csAr^* A t V H •« H H © So.'SfS - - © 43 A ._ M © . -h >A © >4 ^ . .fl -w _rfl Sh r-H -CO a © O Q — d °<^ t>H © _ 2?n3 fl dfl rn^n-A A © <3 C H D H HI 44 d d^oflpfl S O « T s 2 2 0 o ^ddn o q ^ ^ rv> o ^ rd d^ o^i q’ijP ?h .d cd Q ^ ^ 4J df*H HH 0 & A^ sbOd„3 a © d © g pd fl ^ © o3 -33 _^> <0 43 © -d S3 5-t fl .3 a a Hs^a .3 pH fl. © 43 'fl DP • rH d 43 ^no ^2 £ o CO j* £ a Z2 ^ © © nd Id © co?-2 5 * •rH O A A fl GO nfl M © rH 43 rA A © . nnd ■Ss§ 03 © r. .W d fl Sh O Sh © SH O 43 hH 03 © © © co 5- pa fl cs S3 a o . O Sh © 2 > fl a £ 3 &-S g =2 a g -g *K» rd £ •2 J Sh O 03 Ah q_, bO °.a a a o ,d fl O At Ah §fl M ® © 43 * rH © rfl 2 2 dd 0 fl © • rH H C5^ flnS fl © A d co fl © a P fl 2 3 a ^ -2^ H3 A Ah.O fl ’to o co d a 03 o 4J O g § co co * d e 2 ©.a 2 rg g rd Sr © g © © A © A cd © co d o © a M © • rH nd © © £ H s^ A Pj O (Vi fl ° © d 43 a3 •fl ^ o O$